This creamy high protein banana pudding is the perfect single-serve treat when you want something sweet but still want to hit your protein goals. Made with simple ingredients and fresh banana slices, it’s a quick, healthy dessert or snack option that tastes just like the classic Southern favorite — just with a nutritious twist.

I grew up eating banana pudding at every family gathering, every potluck, every holiday where someone’s aunt showed up with a casserole dish and a serving spoon. It was never optional. And honestly, it’s one of those foods I never wanted to give up — I just needed a version that worked with the way I eat now. This is that version.

It comes together in minutes. You’re layering vanilla pudding made with protein powder, fresh banana slices, and a few vanilla wafers for that familiar crunch. It’s rich and creamy and hits every single note the original does — the sweetness, the texture, the way the banana softens into the pudding as it sits. The difference is you’re getting a real protein boost without the sugar crash that used to come with the traditional recipe.

What I love most about this one is that it’s a single serving. No giant trifle dish calling your name from the fridge for three days straight. You make exactly what you need, eat it, and move on with your life. It’s perfect for an after-dinner craving or a midday snack when you need something that feels indulgent but actually supports your goals.

If you’re from the South, you already know banana pudding holds a special place. This version just lets you enjoy it more often without the trade-off. And if you’ve never had banana pudding before — welcome. You’re about to understand what all the fuss is about.

High Protein Banana Pudding Recipe

High Protein Banana Pudding

32g protein/serving


5 minutes to make

5 ingredients

1 serving

Ingredients

150g nonfat Greek yogurt, plain

20g vanilla whey protein powder

2g sugar free banana cream pudding mix

25g thinly sliced banana, 4-5 thin slices

1/2 honey graham cracker sheet

Directions

    • Mix the yogurt, protein powder, and pudding mix together in a bowl.
    • Add half to a small mason jar.
    • Break the 1/2 sheet of graham cracker into a few pieces. Layer them on top of the yogurt.
    • Layer the banana slices over the graham crackers.
    • Layer the rest of the yogurt on top.
    • Add 2 tbsp light cool whip on top. Add a tiny bit of graham cracker crumbs for presentation, if desired (not included in macros).
    • Serve immediately or store in the fridge for a few hours to overnight so the graham crackers can soften. Don’t add the cool whip until ready to serve!

If You're Looking For More

My full cookbook A Month of Family Dinners is available now.

Ready to start tracking? My Macro Counting Starter Kit has a full beginner guide to tracking macros, plus a progress tracking spreadsheet... everything you need for your first month, all in one download.

Looking for personalized macro coaching from a mom who gets it? I keep it affordable with no contracts, limited spots. Learn more here.

Nutrition Info

Search MyFitnessPal for:

RJF High Protein Banana Pudding

Per Serving:

238 calories

32g protein | 23g carbs | 2g fats

+1g fiber

Makes 1 serving

Rachel Jay Farrell intentional family living blog for faith-driven moms

I’m a mom of three who fell in love with nutrition and strength training after having kids. Now I create simple, high-protein recipes and healthy living ideas that help busy moms fuel their families well and make nourishing food a normal part of everyday life. 

Discover more from Rachel Jay Farrell

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading